RSS

“Ranger’s Apprentice book 3: The Icebound Land” – J. Flanagan

14 Sep

RA3

This is a review of “Ranger’s Apprentice book 3: The Icebound Land” by John Flanagan.

This is a continuation of the previous two posts which can be found here (book one) and here (book two).

Kidnapped and taken to a land of snow and ice, Will and Evanlyn are bound for slavery. Halt, determined to find his young apprentice, defies his king and is thrown out of the Rangers. Horace joins him in his journey to the north. On the way they are challenged by knights and warlords. Will they be in time to rescue Will and Evanlyn?

I rather like that this part of the world was based on the world of the vikings. It is all familiar enough to be recognisable, but not a complete copy of the vikings. It is also completely different from the rest of the world presented in the previous two books, and it makes it easy to differentiate.

Horace and Halt’s journey to Skandia is really interesting, presenting more of the world and the different countries. Horace finding something of a temporary teacher in Halt is a nice touch, as is the way he grows as a knight and as a person. Halt being so worried about Will and willing to go as far as he does, is also a nice touch, giving Halt a deeper character than before. And considering everything that actually happens to Will in this book, well, it isn’t exactly something that happens often to the main character in children’s books. It sets this book apart.

Erak is a character that grows on a person in this book. At the end of book two I disliked him, but he grew and changed as a character, and he became one of my favourites by the end of the story. Evanlyn also becomes a good character in this book. She is not my favourite, but she definitely proved to have a spine in this book, and I appreciate that. It is difficult to find good, likable female characters in fantasy stories.

The only thing that I kind of have something against – and that’s such a tiny something that it’s hardly worth mentioning – is just how long Will was incapacitated. But on the other side I am also glad that it took so much time and that it wasn’t rushed. See? Not really worth mentioning.

I can’t wait to read the sequel – “The Battle for Skandia“.

Advertisements
 
4 Comments

Posted by on September 14, 2014 in Books

 

Tags: , , ,

4 responses to ““Ranger’s Apprentice book 3: The Icebound Land” – J. Flanagan

  1. mthomaswhite

    September 14, 2014 at 09:09

    I like your review; however, we differ on one point. I, also, do not like how long Will was incapacitated, but I see the necessity. With him there to shoulder the burden, Evalyn’s character may never have developed. In addition, it was important to show that Will Treaty has a certain promise but is not invincible. In any action or adventure tale, the author runs the risk of creating overpowered characters. The Ranger’s Apprentice series, as a whole, does a good job at avoiding this. Though Will, Halt, and Horace are hero’s, they gained their impressive skills through practice and training (with some natural talent). Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

     
    • redletalis

      September 14, 2014 at 09:14

      That Will being incapacitated makes Evanlyn’s character grow is a very good point and it is true. The same with the rest of the characters. Which is why I simply said that it was such a minor irritation that it was hardly noticable or worth mentioning.

      I also rather like Will’s naivete in that he accepts the roots in good faith.

       
      • mthomaswhite

        September 14, 2014 at 09:21

        Again, a brilliant move on the author’s part. He manages to show a flaw in Will’s character, but it is one with which we can all sympathize. Writing both subtle and profound!

         

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: